96TH GENERAL ASSEMBLY
State of Illinois
2009 and 2010
HB2452

 

Introduced 2/19/2009, by Rep. Dave Winters

 

SYNOPSIS AS INTRODUCED:
 
New Act

    Creates the Science Advisory Board Act. Creates the Science Advisory Board for the purpose of rendering scientific assessment, risk based analysis, and consensus advice upon questions of science posed by the Governor or Legislative Committees having jurisdiction over scientific matters. Provides for appointments to the Board; terms of appointees; and the removal of appointees. Sets forth qualifications for Board members. Prohibits certain persons from participating in the work of the Board. Requires the Board to review and summarize pertinent scientific studies related to charged topics; to summarize findings and recommendations in a manner that is timely, objective, transparent, and understandable by elected officials and policymakers; to achieve consensus in its decision making, if possible, and to provide for reports of minority opinions, if consensus is not possible. Sets out other requirements for Board action. Provides that the Director of the Legislative Research Unit shall act as the Executive Director of the Board and shall assign such clerical and staff support from the Legislative Research Unit staff as is required. Requires members of the Board to be reimbursed from appropriations made by the General Assembly for reasonable expenses incurred as a result of their services.


LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

FISCAL NOTE ACT MAY APPLY

 

 

A BILL FOR

 

HB2452 LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

1     AN ACT concerning State government.
 
2     Be it enacted by the People of the State of Illinois,
3 represented in the General Assembly:
 
4     Section 1. Short title. This Act may be cited as the
5 Science Advisory Board Act.
 
6     Section 5. Purpose. The purpose of the Board is to render
7 scientific assessment, risk based analysis, and consensus
8 advice upon questions of science posed by the Governor or
9 Legislative Committees having jurisdiction over scientific
10 matters.
 
11     Section 10. Creation of the Science Advisory Board. The
12 Science Advisory Board is established and shall be comprised of
13 16 members qualified and appointed as provided under this Act
14 and who shall constitute an independent non-partisan board
15 under the Legislative Research Unit.
 
16     Section 15. Manner of Appointment; Term; Removal.
17     (a) The Governor shall appoint 8 members to the Board (one
18 of whom shall be designated the Chairperson of the Board) and
19 the President of the Illinois Senate, the Speaker of the
20 Illinois House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the
21 Illinois Senate, and the Minority Leader of the Illinois House

 

 

HB2452 - 2 - LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

1 of Representatives shall each appoint 2 members to the Board.
2 Each appointee under this Section must meet the qualifications
3 set forth in Section 20 and be selected from a list of names of
4 scientists submitted for consideration by nationally
5 recognized professional associations serving the academic
6 disciplines listed in Section 20.
7     (b) The term for Board members shall be 4 years, except
8 that the initial Board appointments shall be staggered with the
9 Governor initially appointing 4 members for one year and 4
10 other members for 2 years. The President of the Senate, the
11 Speaker of the Illinois House of Representatives, the Minority
12 Leader of the Illinois Senate, and the Minority Leader of the
13 Illinois House of Representatives shall each initially appoint
14 one member for a term of 3 years and one member for a term of 4
15 years, respectively. Upon the expiration of these initial
16 terms, Board members may be reappointed or the respective
17 appointing authorities shall appoint their replacements for
18 terms of 4 years.
19     (c) The Governor, the President of the Illinois Senate, the
20 Speaker of the Illinois House of Representatives, the Minority
21 Leader of the Illinois Senate, and the Minority Leader of the
22 Illinois House of Representatives may, by a majority vote of
23 those officers, remove a Board member in the event of a
24 professional ethics violation, conflict of interest,
25 criminality, or the member's attainment of employment with an
26 entity of State government other than a university.
 

 

 

HB2452 - 3 - LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

1     Section 20. Qualifications of Board Members.
2     (a) The Board must be comprised of individuals who have
3 reputations for professional competence and technical
4 expertise and who hold doctoral degrees in at least one of the
5 following disciplines:
6         (1) Environmental Health.
7         (2) Toxicology.
8         (3) Engineering.
9         (4) Ecological Science.
10         (5) Economics.
11         (6) Chemistry.
12         (7) Physics.
13         (8) Biology.
14         (9) Forestry.
15         (10) Human Medicine.
16         (11) Statistics.
17         (12) Risk Assessment.
18         (13) Geology.
19         (14) Agricultural Science.
20         (15) Marine Science.
21         (16) Hydrology.
22     (b) The following classes of persons may not be appointed
23 to the Board:
24         (1) State employees other than university employees.
25         (2) Any person affiliated with an organization that

 

 

HB2452 - 4 - LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

1     represents partisan interests (e.g., a lobbying
2     organization).
 
3     Section 25. Duties of the Board.
4     (a) The Board shall:
5         (1) Review and summarize pertinent scientific studies
6     related to charged topics or questions, placing an emphasis
7     on studies and data that are most relevant to the subject
8     of concern.
9         (2) Summarize findings and recommendations in a manner
10     that is timely, objective, transparent, and understandable
11     by elected officials and policymakers.
12         (3) Have the ability to recruit and include expertise
13     from other qualified experts, as needed.
14         (4) Achieve consensus in its decision making, if
15     possible, and provide for reports of minority opinions, if
16     consensus is not possible.
17     (b) Board interpretations, findings, and recommendations
18 must represent the prevailing weight of scientific evidence for
19 a charged topic or question.
20     (c) Board discussions and recommendations shall, when
21 possible, include risk assessments, comparative risk analyses,
22 and economic analyses.
23     (d) The Board's draft findings must be subject to an open
24 public comment period and process before being finalized.
25     (e) Science should be identified and delineated from policy

 

 

HB2452 - 5 - LRB096 08517 JDS 18637 b

1 as separate components that impact risk management and
2 legislative decision-making.
3     (f) Board members must excuse themselves from the Board's
4 consideration of specific topics when such topics represent a
5 conflict of interest.
 
6     Section 30. Staff. The Director of the Legislative Research
7 Unit shall act as the Executive Director of the Board and shall
8 assign clerical and staff support from the Legislative Research
9 Unit staff as required.
 
10     Section 35. Compensation and Expenses. Members of the Board
11 shall be reimbursed from appropriations made by the General
12 Assembly for reasonable expenses incurred as a result of their
13 services.